When a student plays, I sometimes hear a similar sound right as they finish. Here's an example. Listen very carefully to the end of the notes, just as they release. I placed the microphone inches away from the side of their face....
If you listen carefully, you'll hear a little "click" sound as the notes end.
What is going one here?
I have this saying:
Lungs deal in pounds. Lips deal in ounces.
I think the lungs are trying to force more air than the lips need. That causes the throat area to "lock up" in resistance to all that air pressure.
At the top of the throat we all have a soft palate.
This soft palate can prevent air from escaping through the nose unintentionally. Try this experiment:
- Blow air (mouth shaped like a small O)
- As you blow, plug the opening with your finger.
- Notice that the air doesn't escape through the nose. Why? I think it is because the soft palate is blocking the air.
That popping/nasal vent sound at the end of notes is, I think, a sign that the student is putting the air under more pressure than the lips need and is thereby creating an isometric situation where they are effectively working against themselves. I briefly referenced this concept in a previous blog post called "The 47 Pound Pencil".
For some reason this reminds me of that legendary creature, the "push me, pull you"
If you're a teacher, listen for that little "nasal vent" sound at the end of notes. It is usually accompanied by a rather muffled tone and the general sense that the student is working too hard. (also the dreaded "wah" often appears).
How to fix this? There's no one solution but, generally, you need to teach the student (or yourself) to blow with less force.
The practice mute trick often helps
- Play loud into the mute.
- Remove the mute and just blow big and easy.
- Notice how the notes seem to fall out of the bell without much effort.
If you're a teacher, listen carefully for that little pop of the "nasal vent" as the student finishes a note. You might be surprised how often you hear it.